Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-25wd4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T20:21:35.665Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Cow Is a Mother, Mothers Can Do Anything for Their Children!” Gaushalas as Landscapes of Anthropatriarchy and Hindu Patriarchy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2020

Yamini Narayanan Open the ORCID record for Yamini Narayanan [Opens in a new window]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article argues that gaushalas, or cow shelters, in India are mobilized as sites of Hindutva or Hindu ultranationalism, where it is a “vulnerable” Hindu Indian nation—or the “Hindu mother cow” as Mother India—who needs “sanctuary” from predatory Muslim males. Gaushalas are rendered spaces of (re)production of cows as political, religious, and economic capital, and sustained by the combined and compatible narratives of “anthropatriarchy” and Hindu patriarchy. Anthropatriarchy is framed as the human enactment of gendered oppressions upon animal bodies, and is crucial to sustaining all animal agriculture. Hindu patriarchy refers to the instrumentalization of female and feminized bodies (women, cows, “Mother India”) as “mothers” and cultural guardians of a “pure” Hindu civilization. Both patriarchies commodify bovine motherhood and breastmilk. which this article frames as a feminist issue. Through empirical research, this article demonstrates that gaushalas generally function as spaces of exploitation, incarceration, and gendered violence for the animals. The article broadens posthumanist feminist theory to illustrate how bovine bodies, akin to women's bodies, are mobilized as productive, reproductive, and symbolic capital to advance Hindu extremism and ultranationalism. It subjectifies animal bodies as landscapes of nation‐making using ecofeminism and its subfield of vegan feminism.

Type
Articles
Information
Hypatia , Volume 34 , Issue 2 , Spring 2019 , pp. 195 - 221
Copyright
Copyright © 2019 by Hypatia, Inc.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adams, Carol J. 1991. Ecofeminism and the eating of animals. Hypatia 6 (1): 125–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Adams, Carol J. 2010. Why feminist‐vegan now? Feminism and Psychology 20 (3): 302–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Albanese, Catherine L. 1990. Nature Religion in America: From the Algonkian Indians to the New Age. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Alger, Janet M., and Alger, Steven F. 2003. Cat culture: The social world of a cat shelter. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
Amir, Lisa Helen, and Lumley, Judith. 2006. Women's experience of lactational mastitis: “I have never felt worse”. Australian Family Physician 35 (9): 745–7.Google Scholar
Anand, D. 2007. The violence of security: Hindu nationalism and the politics of representing “the Muslim” as a danger. The Round Table 94 (379): 203–15.Google Scholar
Basu, Amrita. 1999. Women's activism and the vicissitudes of Hindu nationalism. Journal of Women's History 10 (4): 104–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Basu, Amrita. 2011. Appropriating gender. In Appropriating gender: Women's activism and politicized religion in South Asia, ed. Jeffery, Patricia and Basu, Amrita. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
BBC. 2017. Why are Indian women wearing cow masks? http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-40404102.Google Scholar
Becker, Johanna, Reist, Martin, and Steiner, Adrian. 2014. Factors influencing the attitudes of cattle veterinarians, farmers, and claw trimmers towards the pain associated with the treatment of sole ulcers and the sensitivity to pain of dairy cows. The Veterinary Journal 200 (1): 38–43.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Blowey, Roger, and Edmondson, Peter. 2010. Mastitis control in dairy herds, 2nd ed. Wallingford, UK: CABI.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgat, Florence. 2004. Non‐violence towards animals in the thinking of Gandhi: The problem of animal husbandry. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 17 (3): 223–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chakravarti, A. K. 1985. Cattle Development Problems and Programs in India: A Regional Analysis. GeoJournal 10 (1): 21–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chaudhuri, Una. 2017. The stage lives of animals: Zooesis and performance. Abingdon, UK: Routledge.Google Scholar
Chigateri, Shraddha. 2008. “Glory to the cow”: Cultural difference and social justice in the food hierarchy in India. South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 31 (1): 10–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Collard, Rosemary‐Claire, and Gillespie, Kathryn. 2015. Doing critical animal geographies: Future directions. In Critical animal geographies: Politics, intersections and hierarchies in a multispecies World, ed. Gillespie, Kathryn and Collard, Rosemary‐Claire. New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Common Cause v. Union of India. 2000. (Unreported, Delhi High Court, Singh and Sodhi JJ, 3 November 2000).Google Scholar
Cusack, Carmen M. 2013. Feminism and husbandry: Drawing the fine line between mine and bovine. Journal for Critical Animal Studies 11 (1): 24–44.Google Scholar
Dave, Naisargi N. 2017. Something, everything, nothing; Or, cows, dogs, and maggots. Social Text 35 (1): 37–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davis, Karen. 2017. Interspecies sexual assault: A moral perspective. https://www.animalliberationcurrents.com/interspecies-sexual-assault/#more-1680.Google Scholar
Deckha, Maneesha. 2012. Toward a postcolonial, posthumanist feminist theory: Centralizing race and culture in feminist work on nonhuman animals. Hypatia 27 (3): 527–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deckha, Maneesha. 2015. Vulnerability, equality, and animals. Canadian Journal of Women & the Law 27 (1): 47–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
FAO. 2002. Livestock diversity: Keepers' rights, shared benefits and pro‐poor policies. http://www.fao.org/3/a-x6104e.pdf.Google Scholar
Francione, Gary. 2010. Animal welfare and the moral status of nonhuman animals. Law, Culture and the Humanities 6 (1): 24–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Francione, Gary L., and Anna, Charlton E. 2017. Animal rights. In The Oxford handbook of animal studies, ed. Kalof, Linda. New York: University of Oxford Press.Google Scholar
Gaard, Greta. 2013. Toward a feminist postcolonial milk studies. American Quarterly 65 (2): 595–618.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gade, Daniel W. 2000. Llamas and alpacas. In The Cambridge world history of food, ed. Kiple, Kenneth F. and Coneè Ornelas, Kriemhild. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Gandhi, Mahatma K. 1925. Scheme for cow protection. Ahmedabad: Navajivan.Google Scholar
Gandhi, Mahatma K. 1999. Speech on cow protection, Bettiah [October 9, 1917] in The collected works of Mahatma Gandhi, Vol. 16. New Delhi: Publications Division Government of India.Google Scholar
Ganguli, Kisari Mohan. 1896. The Mahabharata of Krishna‐Dwaipayana Vyasa [translation]. http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/maha/index.htm.Google Scholar
Gillespie, Kathryn. 2014. Sexualized violence and the gendered commodification of the animal body in Pacific northwest US dairy production. Gender, Place and Culture 21 (10): 1321–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gillespie, Kathryn. 2018. The cow with ear tag #1389. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Griffith, Ralph T. H. 1896. The hymns of the Rgveda. New Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.Google Scholar
Grillo, Robert. 2016. Farm to fable: The fictions of our animal‐consuming culture. Danvers, Mass.: Vegan Press.Google Scholar
Gruen, Lori. 1993. Dismantling oppression: An analysis of the connection between women and animals. In Ecofeminism, ed. Gaard, G. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
Gruen, Lori, ed. 2014. The ethics of captivity. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gupta, Charu. 2001. The icon of mother in late colonial North India: “Bharat mata”, “matri bhasha” and “gau mata”. Economic and Political Weekly 36 (45): 4291–99.Google Scholar
Hansen, Thomas Blom. 1994. Controlled emancipation: Women and Hindu nationalism. European Journal of Development Research 6 (2): 82–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hurn, Samantha. 2017. Animals as producers, consumers and consumed: The complexities of trans‐species sustenance in a multi‐faith community. Ethnos: Journal of Anthropology 82 (2): 213–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
India Today/YouTube. 2016. Beef market in Rampur, UP exposed. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Idv8vbMqgzw (accessed January 11, 2018).Google Scholar
The Indian Express. 2017a. At “cow hospital” in Punjab, signs of sword and acid attacks on bovines. The Indian Express. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/at-cow-hospital-in-punjab-signs-of-sword-and-acid-attacks-on-bovines/.Google Scholar
The Indian Express. 2017b. Muslim man in Ahmedabad to sit on fast to spread message of cow protection. The Indian Express. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/muslim-man-in-ahmedabad-to-sit-on-fast-to-spread-message-of-cow-protection-4744673/.Google Scholar
Jaigopal Garodia Foundations v. T.R. Srinivasan. 2004. CriLJ 2420 (April 1, 2004).Google Scholar
Jain, Pankaj. 2014. Bovine dharma: Nonhuman animals and the Swadhyaya Parivar. In Asian perspectives on animal ethics: Rethinking the nonhuman, ed. Dalal, Neil and Taylor, Chloë. New York: Taylor and Francis.Google Scholar
Jasper, J., and Weary, D. M. 2002. Effects of ad libitum milk intake on dairy calves. Journal of Dairy Science 85 (11): 3054–58.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jenkins, Stephanie. 2012. Returning the ethical and political to animal studies. Hypatia 27 (3): 504–10.Google Scholar
Kim, Claire Jean. 2015. Dangerous crossings: Race, species, and nature in a multicultural age. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
King, A. S. 2012. Krishna's cows: ISKCON's animal theology and practice. Journal of Animal Ethics 2 (2): 179–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Korom, Frank J. 2000. Holy cow! The apotheosis of Zebu, or why the cow is sacred in Hinduism. Asian Folklore Studies 59 (2): 181–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kurien, Verghese. 2005. I too have a dream … [as told to Gouri Salvi]. New Delhi: Lotus Collection, Roli Books.Google Scholar
Lodrick, Deryck O. 1981. Sacred cows, sacred places: Origins and survival of animal homes in India. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Lodrick, Deryck O. 2008. Goshalas. In Enclyclopedia of religion and nature, vol. 1, ed. Taylor, Bron. London: Continuum.Google Scholar
Maan Mandir Gaushala. 2017. http://maanmandir.org/gaushala/Google Scholar
Makhijani, H. J. 1956. Gaushalas and pinjrapoles in India. New Delhi: Central Council of Gosamvardhana.Google Scholar
Maroney, Heather Jon. 1985. Embracing motherhood: New feminist theory. Canadian Journal of Political and Social Theory 11 (1–2): 40–64.Google Scholar
Mohan, C. Madan. 1989. Dairy management in India: A study in Andhra Pradesh. Delhi: Mittal Publications.Google Scholar
Moore, J. W. 2016. Introduction: Anthropocene or capitalocene? Nature, history, and the crisis of capitalism. In Anthropocene or capitalocene: Nature, history, and the crisis of capitalism, ed. Moore, J. W. Oakland, Calif.: PM Press.Google Scholar
Moritz, Mark. 2008. A critical examination of honour cultures and herding societies in Africa. African Studies Review 51 (2): 99–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Narayanan, Yamini. 2018a. Cow protectionism and bovine frozen semen farms in India: Analysing cruelty, speciesism, and climate change. Society and Animals 26 (1): 13–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Narayanan, Yamini. 2018b. Animal ethics and Hinduism's milking, mothering legends: Analysing Krishna the butter thief and the ocean of milk. Sophia 27 (1): 133–49.Google Scholar
Oltenacu, P. A., and Broom, D. M. 2010. The impact of genetic selection for increased milk yield on the welfare of dairy cows. Animal Welfare 19 (S): 39–49.Google Scholar
Pachirat, Timothy. 2011. Every twelve seconds: industrialized slaughter and the politics of sight. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Pathmeda Online Store. 2016. Gavyamart. http://www.gavyamart.com/.Google Scholar
Pellow, David Naguib. 2014. Total liberation: The power and promise of animal rights and the radical earth movement. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
People's Union for Democratic Rights. 2009. Dalit lynching at Dulina: Cow‐protection, caste and communalism. In Human rights and peace: Ideas, laws, institutions, and movements, ed. Kumar Singh, Ujjwal. New Delhi: SAGE Publications.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Phillips, Clive. 2002. Cattle behaviour and welfare, 2nd edition. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Science.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
RSPCA Victoria. 2018. How much milk should dairy calves be fed? http://kb.rspca.org.au/how-much-milk-should-dairy-calves-be-fed_704.htmlGoogle Scholar
Ryder, Richard D. 2004. Speciesism revisited. Think 2 (6): 83–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Seager, Joni. 2003. Pepperoni or broccoli? On the cutting wedge of environmental feminism. Gender, Place and Culture 10 (2): 167–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sharpes, Donald K. 2006. Sacred bull, holy cow: A cultural study of civilization's most important animal. New York: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Springer, Simon, and Le Billon, Philippe. 2016. Violence and space: An introduction to the geographies of violence. Political Geography 52 (June): 1–3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stockler, Richard. 2015. Heifer development: From weaning to calving. In Bovine reproduction, ed. Hopper, R. M. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.Google Scholar
Subramaniam, Mangala. 2014. Resisting gendered religious nationalism: The case of religious‐based violence in Gujarat, India. Gendered Perspectives on Conflict and Violence 18B: 73–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Torres, B. 2007. Making a killing: The political economy of animal rights. Oakland, Calif.: AK Press.Google Scholar
The Tribune. 2016. 8,122 cows died since Jan at Hingonia gaushala: Rajasthan govt. http://www.tribuneindia.com/news/nation/8-122-cows-died-since-jan-at-hingonia-gaushala-rajasthan-govt/276859.html.Google Scholar
Twine, Richard. 2010. Intersectional disgust? Animals and (eco)feminism. Feminism and Psychology 20 (3): 397–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Valiani, Arafaat A. 2011. Militant publics in India: Physical culture and violence in the making of a modern polity. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walby, Sylvia. 1986. Patriarchy at work. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Wadiwel, Dinesh Joseph. 2015. The war against animals. New York: Brill Rodopi.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yang, Ananda. 1980. Sacred symbol and sacred space in rural India: Community mobilization in the “anti‐cow” killing riot of 1893. Comparative Studies in Society and History 22 (4): 576–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yuval‐Davis, Nira. 1993. Gender and nation. Ethnic and Racial Studies 16 (4): 621–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar