Systematic ReviewSpinal immobilisaton in pre-hospital and emergency care: A systematic review of the literature
Section snippets
What is known
- •
Spinal immobilisation is a mainstay of trauma management in pre-hospital and emergency care environments.
- •
Spinal immobilisation is frequently used in pre-hospital and emergency care environments.
What this paper adds?
- •
There is no high level evidence to assess the efficacy of spinal immobilisation in the pre-hospital or emergency settings.
- •
There is evidence that for some patients spinal immobilisation causes harm.
- •
Decisions to use spinal immobilisation should be based on careful assessment of risk vs benefit in individual patients.
Method
In February 2015, we performed a systematic literature review of English language publications from 1966 to February 2015 indexed in MEDLINE and Cochrane library using the search terms: ‘spinal injuries’ OR ‘spinal cord injuries’ AND ‘emergency treatment’ OR ‘emergency care’ OR ‘first aid’ AND immobilisation. EMBASE was searched for keywords ‘spinal injury OR ‘spinal cord injury’ OR ‘spine fracture AND ‘emergency care’ OR ‘prehospital care’. Adjacent terms for both searches were
- •
‘spin$ or cerv$
Results
There were 47 studies meeting inclusion criteria for further review. Ten studies were case series (LOE IV) and there were 37 studies from which data were extrapolated from healthy volunteers, cadavers or multiple trauma patients; extrapolated data does not have a level of evidence. There were 15 studies that were supportive of spinal immobilisation, 13 studies neutral for spinal immobilisation and 19 studies opposing spinal immobilisation (Table 2).
Discussion
The results of this systematic review yielded 47 studies examining the outcomes of spinal immobilisation in pre-hospital or emergency care settings. Overall, there were 15 studies supportive of spinal immobilisation, 13 studies neutral for spinal immobilisation and 19 studies opposing spinal immobilisation. There were no published high-level studies that assessed the efficacy of spinal immobilisation in the pre-hospital or emergency care setting and no randomised controlled trials were found.
Conclusion
There are no published high-level studies that assess the efficacy of spinal immobilisation in the pre-hospital and emergency care settings. Almost all of the current evidence related to spinal immobilisation is extrapolated data, mostly from healthy volunteers. There were no studies that showed spinal immobilisation improved neurological outcomes as all studies using neurological outcome as an endpoint were neutral due to high mortality rates from other causes (mostly gunshot wounds). Based on
Provenance and conflict of interest
Professor Julie Considine is a Deputy Editor of the Australasian Emergency Nursing Journal but had no role to play in the peer review or editorial decision-making process whatsoever, and was blinded to this process. There were no other conflicts of interest declared with this manuscript. This paper was not commissioned.
Acknowledgment
This systematic review was unfunded.
References (62)
Clinical features, patterns of referral and out of hospital transport events for patients with suspected isolated spinal injury
Injury
(2001)- et al.
Learning the lessons from conflict: pre-hospital cervical spine stabilisation following ballistic neck trauma
Injury
(2009) - et al.
Neck collar used in treatment of victims of urban motorcycle accidents: over-or underprotection?
Am J Emerg Med
(2011) - et al.
Cervical spine stabilization in pediatric patients: evaluation of current techniques
Ann Emerg Med
(1987) - et al.
A radiographic comparison of prehospital cervical immobilization methods
Ann Emerg Med
(1987) - et al.
The effectiveness of strapping techniques in spinal immobilization
Ann Emerg Med
(1994) - et al.
Comparison of two new immobilization collars
Ann Emerg Med
(1992) Effectiveness of cervical collars in limiting movement
Physiotherapy
(1991)- et al.
The efficacy and comfort of full-body vacuum splints for cervical-spine immobilization
J Emerg Med
(1996) - et al.
Cervical collars are insufficient for immobilizing an unstable cervical spine injury
J Emerg Med
(2011)