Discussion paperInitial emergency nursing management of patients with severe traumatic brain injury: Development of an evidence-based care bundle for the Thai emergency department context
Introduction
In Thailand, incidence of hospitalisation from traumatic brain injury (TBI) is increasing,1 mostly due to the severity and the impact of road traffic accidents (RTAs).2 According to the Bureau of Policy and Strategy reports, the number of patients with severe TBI rose dramatically by approximately 18%, from 70,134 cases in 2007 to 82,993 cases in 2010, in every region of Thailand.1 RTAs are the major cause of severe TBI.2 In 2007, a study of severe injury due to transport accidents in 28 Thai regional and tertiary hospitals indicated that approximately 6% (n = 4852) died from RTAs, and 80% (n = 62,934) were seriously injured.2 Almost 30% (n = 39,911) of RTA cases studied sustained isolated head injuries, and approximately 17% (n = 23,023) had multiple injuries.2 Due to the increasing number of persons suffering TBI and specifically severe TBI, the management of severe TBI is a continuing challenge for Thai healthcare providers, particularly for emergency department (ED) clinicians providing initial care for patients with severe TBI.
Severe TBI is defined as a Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score of 8 or less.3, 4 Evidence-based guidelines for the management of severe TBI initially developed in Western countries have been adapted for use in Thai ED settings.5 However, there are several gaps identified in relation to implementing an evidenced-based guideline for care of patients with severe TBI in the Thai ED context. Firstly, Thai emergency care varies greatly from Western countries, particularly in terms of trauma care systems and emergency care facilities. In Western countries, emergency medical services personnel-paramedics are often the first healthcare providers to assess and treat patients with severe TBI according to the advanced trauma life support (ATLS) protocols.6 In addition, the paramedics in Western countries are commonly enabled to commence advanced treatment including medication administration in the field.7, 8 In Thailand, however, pre-hospital care for patients with severe TBI is variable depending on the attending staff and equipment available on the scene,9 and the essential care for patients with severe TBI according to ATLS concepts are mostly commenced in the ED.5 Second, the majority of the guidelines for the management of patients with severe TBI focus on physician care5, 10 however in Thailand like many other countries, it is emergency nurses who are responsible for emergency care delivery and who are with the patient for the entirety of their ED episode of care. Physician input into the care of patients with severe TBI is episodic and intermittent and it is emergency nurses who make decisions regarding type and frequency of physiological monitoring, cervical spine precautions, patient positioning, and urgent CT scan administration.11, 12 Third, there is known variation in Thai nurses’ knowledge and care practices for patients with severe TBI.13 Some elements of variation are placing patients at risk of harm particularly increased intracranial pressure and risk of secondary brain injury.13 Finally, in Thailand there are no specific evidence-based practice guidelines available for emergency nursing management of patients with severe TBI that are suitable for the Thai ED context.
The aim of this paper is to describe the development of an evidence-based care bundle for initial emergency nursing management of patients with severe TBI for use in a Thai ED context. For the purposes of the development of the care bundle, ‘severe TBI’ was defined as a Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score of 8 or less, and ‘initial’ emergency nursing management was defined as nursing care delivered to the patients with severe TBI from arrival to the ED until the patient was transferred to another department. The term of ‘care bundle’ is defined as a small number of evidence-based practice elements; generally limited to three to five key elements, which, when executed together, result in better outcomes than when implemented individually.14
The care bundle for initial emergency nursing management of patients with severe TBI was developed specifically for the Thai ED context so the ED structure, staffing, processes and resources of the emergency healthcare system were major considerations during the development process. It is therefore important to understand the ED context in Thailand and the local conditions at the regional hospital where the care bundle was developed and then implemented so the sections to follow will provide detail about the structure and process of emergency care in Thailand and specifically at the hospital where the care bundle was developed.
Section snippets
Emergency care in Thailand
In Thailand, severe TBI patients will be commonly taken to an ED by an ambulance through the emergency medical service (EMS) system, which has responded to an emergency ‘1669’ call. For patients with severe TBI, ED medical and nursing staff working as ALS personnel will be the first healthcare providers to go out as part of the EMS/ambulance response. Larger government and private hospitals, mostly around the centre of Thailand, tend to have the best equipment, and the most adequate staffing of
Review of the literature and current guidelines
There are a number of evidence-based guidelines for the initial management of severe TBI4, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 that span pre-hospital care, ED care and management in the intensive care unit. The majority of these guidelines recommend immediate resuscitation of the patient and prevention of secondary insult. As the focus of the care bundle was the initial emergency nursing management of patients with severe TBI, the evidence related to ED care will be summarised in the section to follow and was
Development of an evidence-based care bundle
There were seven theoretical steps used in the development of the care bundle31 (Fig. 1).
Conclusion
Thai emergency nurses play a vital role in caring for patients with severe TBI, and are an important part of the healthcare team throughout the resuscitation phase. They are also responsible for continuous physiological monitoring, and detecting deterioration associated with increased intracranial pressure and preventing secondary brain injury. A care bundle is one method of promoting consistent, evidence-based emergency nursing care of patients with severe TBI, decreasing unnecessary
Provenance and conflict of interest
Professor Julie Considine is a Deputy Editor of Australian Emergency Nursing Journal but has not been involved in the review process for this paper. This paper was not commissioned.
Funding
This study is an unfunded PhD study. Ms Damkliang is supported by a scholarship from Faculty of Nursing, Prince of Songkla University, Thailand.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank the following people for their assistance with development and review of the care bundle: Praphun Somporn, MD; Kesinee Sae-Heng, MD; Sorajanee Kanchanaprapas, MD; Tanom Phibalsak, RN; Pacharee Prommoon, RN; Metaporn Jangtrakul, RN; Subai Suwanwong, RN; Pratimaporn Pengchan, RN; Wanwisa Paphakdee, RN; Korlic Bubasor, RN; and Assistant Professor Luppana Kitrungrote.
References (33)
- et al.
Prehospital endotracheal intubation in patients with severe traumatic brain injury: guidelines versus reality
Resuscitation
(2009) - et al.
Thai emergency nurses’ management of patients with severe traumatic brain injury: comparison of knowledge and clinical management with best available evidence
Australas Emerg Nurs J
(2013) - Bureau of Policy and Strategy, Ministry of Public Health, Thailand. Health status information. Available at...
Severe injury due to transport accidents
(2007)Traumatic brain injury: definition and nomenclature
Guidelines for the management of severe traumatic brain injury
(2007)- et al.
Management of increase intracranial pressure in severe head injury patient
Neurol Surg
(2011) Initial assessment and management
- et al.
Prehospital rapid sequence intubation improves functional outcome for patients with severe traumatic brain injury: a randomized controlled trial
Ann Surg
(2010) - et al.
Emergency medicine
Bangkok Med J
(2011)
The impacts and outcomes of implementing head injury guidelines: clinical experience in Thailand
Emerg Med J
Critical care in the emergency department: traumatic brain injury
Emerg Med J
Nursing care of the acute head injury: a review of the evidence
Nurs Crit Care
Statistics in emergency medical services
Guidelines for prehospital management of traumatic brain injury
Cited by (13)
A description of the self-perceived educational needs of emergency nurses in Durban, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa
2018, African Journal of Emergency MedicineCitation Excerpt :In an Australian study showing urgent need for education and training in emergency nursing, preference was indicated for ongoing professional development using scenario-based, context-specific education [15]. Familiarity with care bundles can help to promote consistent, evidence-based emergency nursing care [31] and educational hand-outs, demonstrations and updated protocols can also enhance nurses’ knowledge and skills [30]. Keeping up to date with current evidence-based practice is best achieved through continuing professional development and follow-up.
Nurses' perceptions of using an evidence-based care bundle for initial emergency nursing management of patients with severe traumatic brain injury: A qualitative study
2015, International Emergency NursingCitation Excerpt :The Knowledge to Action Framework (Graham et al., 2006) provided rigorous processes to develop and implement the care bundle in a particular context, while the seven theoretical steps for care bundle development by Fulbrook and Mooney (2003) guided the process of developing the care bundle. Details of the care bundle development process have been published elsewhere (Damkliang et al., 2014). The care bundle was developed specifically for implementation in one Thai ED including consideration of the structure, staffing, processes and resources of the emergency healthcare system, and more specifically the ED setting (Table 1).
Using an evidence-based care bundle to improve Thai emergency nurses' knowledge of care for patients with severe traumatic brain injury
2015, Nurse Education in PracticeCitation Excerpt :This care bundle was developed by the researchers, focusing on four major elements of emergency care and using a primary survey approach: a) airway management and cervical spine protection, b) oxygenation and ventilation management, c) circulation and fluid balance, and d) disability and intracranial pressure management. Details of the care bundle development process are published elsewhere (Damkliang et al., 2014) and a summary of the care bundle is presented in Fig. 1. Care bundle development and implementation was supported by key stakeholders, including the ED head nurse, the ED physician, the neurosurgeon, and the Advanced Trauma Life Support certified anaesthetist.
Applying the Ethical Principle of Social Benefits in Nursing Research in Developing Countries: the Case of Jordan
2022, Journal of Academic EthicsEvidence–practice gaps in initial neuro-protective nursing care: A mixed methods study of Thai patients with moderate or severe traumatic brain injury
2021, International Journal of Nursing PracticeOptimizing the Prehospital-Hospital Emergency Care Path Application Value in Emergency Treatment of Patients with Cerebral Hemorrhage
2021, Journal of Healthcare Engineering